The Lost Gospel of Judas
Is it Real?

http://theonlinebibleschool.net/file.php/1/Gospel_of_Judas.jpg

 The discovery of an ancient codex (book) called the “Gospel of Judas” brought National Geographic and the History Channel to bring to light an old cult in the Church that dates back as far as the 2nd century A.D. This exposure has helped give rise to the re-entry of the cultic belief of “Gnosticism” to the American people. The Gospel of Judas, which is one element of Gnosticism was introduced as an ancient book which might have some validity of truth. The story goes like this: Jesus considered Judas Iscariot His favorite disciple, so He gave him a “secret gospel” the week before He died on the cross. Jesus’ other eleven disciples were so jealous and enraged with Judas, they stoned him to death. Before he “was killed,” however, Judas passed this secret gospel on to someone who, over 100 years later, had someone else write it for others to follow.

Sethianismhttp://theonlinebibleschool.net/file.php/1/Sethianism.jpg

The Gospel of Judas belongs to a vein of Gnosticism called Sethianism, meaning those who looked to Seth as their spiritual ancestor instead of his father Adam. Jesus supposedly was equated with Seth, being the 2nd Seth, not Adam as the New Testament claims. According to this gospel, Judas was supposed to have been obedient to the “stars” so that by Jesus’ “mortal” death on the cross, Judas would become the “redeemer” to the people – a place that was reserved for Jesus only. According to Sethians, Judas is one worthy to be worshipped.  It is estimated that this gospel was written sometime after the heavy infiltration of Gnosticism in the Church after 140 A.D. This gospel is a combination of pagan mythology and Gnostic teachings.

The inconsistencies of the Gospel of Judas

A person can’t help but ask why Jesus would invest His life in twelve disciples and then give a secret gospel to only one person. That was so contrary to Jesus’ message to His disciples to “go and make disciples of all nations.” It would take large numbers of people, having one plan and one purpose to do such a feat.  Another question arises: Why would Jesus’ disciples kill one of their own? Jesus had just spent His whole ministry investing in His disciples so they would become like Him – humble, loving, compassionate, and caring toward one another. Jesus trained them so they could pass those same fruits, which were a part of Him, on to the next generation of people. They were not murderers, seeking revenge. If they were, Jesus would have been a bad judge of character in choosing His disciples. We must remember that Jesus’ whole ministry was based on love and the issues of the heart.  The teachings of the Gospel of Judas go contrary to what Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John tell us of Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection in the four gospels. It teachings violate the Hebrew Torah and the writings of the prophets in the Old Testament scriptures and the New Testament writers as well. In other words, this one little book violates the whole Bible. Who could hold validity in one book which disclaims Jesus as the Son of God when there are over 300 prophecies of Him throughout the Old Testament. Those prophecies were then manifested in the writings of the Gospels when Jesus came as the Redeemer of mankind and Son of God. The Epistle and the book of Revelation writings reaffirm Jesus as well. So then, how can one book cancel out 66 authorized, accepted and proven books?

Docetism

Since Sethianism has twists of Gnosticm, it would be helpful to have a little understanding of what Gnosticism entails. As far back as 60 A.D. a strange cult had crept into the Church at large called Docetism. Docetism, derived its name from the Greek word “dokeo” which means “to appear or seem.” As an early Christian heresy, Docetism claimed that Christ was not truly human, meaning He did not possess a physical body. What was seen of Him was only a ghost-like figure. Christ appeared as human, but in essence was simply a spirit in the form of a body1- a figment of one’s imagination. If this belief was true, Jesus then did not come in the flesh, shedding His physical blood on Calvary, because He was only a spirit. If his physical blood was not shed and He did not die, there would be no atonement for the sins of mankind. If God did not raise Jesus from the dead, there would be no salvation for mankind. Christianity would, therefore, be completely null and void because salvation only comes through Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection. Without it, there is no eternal life. Docetism then grew into other cultic beliefs within the Church.

Strong warnings to the churches by the Apostles Paul and John

The Apostles Paul and John left strong words of warning with the churches in Colossae and Ephesus. These heretical beliefs had infiltrating the Church through false teachers, and not only caused division, but were pulling the Church away from the Truth of the Gospel of Jesus Christ.  By doing some background study of the churches in Asia Minor during the 1st century, it becomes apparent why the Apostle Paul wrote his letters to those churches. He wrote strongly to the church at Colossae regarding a false teaching that became known as the Colossian Heresy. This heresy had its roots in Docetism. Throughout his writings (early 60s A.D.), Paul yearned for the people to turn away from this false teaching, which in essence nullified the blood sacrifice of Jesus. The same practice was going on in Ephesus with just a little different twist. The Apostle Paul wrote to his beloved followers, with whom he had spent so much time on his mission journeys and gave the simple message of the Gospel, lifting up Jesus and pleading with the people to cast aside any other teachings but that of Jesus’ shed blood and resurrection.  The Apostle John, in his last writings (around 90 A.D.), warned the Church against heresies that denied the life, death, and resurrection of our Lord. Referring to the growing cultic beliefs of Docetism, John wrote the following to the churches:

1 John 4:1-3 “Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world. Hereby know ye the Spirit of God: Every spirit that confesseth that JesusChrist is come in the flesh is of God: And every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God: and this is that spirit of antichrist, whereof ye have heard that it should come; and even nowalready is it in the world.” KJV

2 John 7 For many deceivers are entered into the world, who confess not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh. This is a deceiver and an antichrist.” KJV

The leader of Gnosticism?

Gnosticism (silent “G”) had infiltrated the Western Empire churches around 140 A.D. by a man named Marcion.  Wanting a platform to spread his heretical beliefs, Marcion offered an enormous sum of money to the Roman Church (headquarters for the Western churches at that time) with the provision that he was given oversight over church congregations. The Roman Church agreed and Marcion set out to build his heretical empire. During the next four years Marcion spread his Gnostic beliefs throughout the Western churches and Gnosticism became a real threat to the Church at large. When the Roman Church discovered his heresy, they returned the money to Marcion and excommunicated Him from the Church. Sadly, Marcion had a large enough following by this time, so he simply started his own movement elsewhere. By 160 A.D. there were more Gnostic believers in the Church than the believers who were following the teachings of the original apostles.

Teachings of the Gnostics

Gnosticism added to the claims of Docetism (see above), carrying earlier roots of Asian, Babylonian, Egyptian, Greek and Syrian pagan religions. It then began infiltrating itself into Judaism and Christianity. The basic fundamental belief was that Gnostics alone had secret knowledge about God, humanity and the rest of the universe, of which “other Christians and the general population were unaware.” They claimed that all matter, including the physical body was evil. Since the human body was evil, Jesus then could not have come down to earth in a body, but simply as a spirit. What was seen by man as a body only appeared to be a body. They believed His physical presence was simply His spirit, and it wasn’t real. This Gnostic belief taught that man is composed of body, soul, and spirit, which is scriptural, except that since the body and the soul are part of man’s earthly existence, they were evil. Their claim was that within man’s soul is the spirit, which is the only divine substance. The spirit within man is asleep and ignorant; therefore, needs to be awakened and liberated by knowledge. For Gnostics, salvation then can only come through knowledge. Man must be awakened and brought “to a realization of his true nature. Mankind is continuously moving toward the Omega Point, the Great day when all must graduate or fall. This day is also the Day of Judgment in which only those who have entered the Path of Transfiguration, and are being reborn, can return to the Treasury of Light.  The chief goal of the Gnostics was to become free forever from the taint of matter and the shackles of the body, and to return to the heavenly realm as Pure Spirit, totally rejecting any idea of the resurrection of the body. To be set free, Gnostics had to search Scriptures looking for hidden meanings to continuously increase their knowledge. The spirit would be awakened by this knowledge so the inner man could be released from his earthly body and return to the realm of light where the soul would reunite with God. As the soul ascends, however, it needs to penetrate through the cosmic spheres, which was separate from the heavenly destiny. Soul ascension was not an easy task. The Gnostic belief taught that the earth was surrounded by seven cosmic spheres that were ruled by archons, or spiritual principalities and powers, which guarded their spheres. Their purpose was to bar the souls who are seeking to ascend from the realm of darkness and captivity to the higher realm of light above.  To ascend through it, one must learn knowledge, and only certain formulas were revealed to the informed. (1)

Fragments of these same metaphysical teachings can also be found today in the New Age Movement and in Mormonism

The “secret gospel” of Judas encompassed some of these beliefs, and its teachings claim that Judas was “supposedly” obedient to the cosmic “stars.” This kind of belief also had its roots in Platonic philosophy1 and can be seen in Mormonism and some of the New Age teachings of today.

The Attitude of Gnostics Toward Other Christians

Gnostics considered themselves superior to other Christians; in fact, they looked down on those who didn’t believe as they did. Their condescending attitude created a variety of ethical behaviors to where some separated themselves from all evil matter so they would not be contaminated, while others adopted very liberal ethics, participating in all sorts of physical indulgences. They believed that since they received this special divine knowledge and were informed about their divine nature, they could then live as they pleased. Ireaneus, one of the earliest church fathers of the 2nd century was determined to expose any Gnostic heresy and wrote two book (called treaties) on them. He refutiated any Gnostic teachings in his two books Against Heresies and The Demonstration of the Apostolic Preaching. The Gospel of Judas would have been one of those heresies.

The threat against Christianity

The Gnostic beliefs represent a denial of several crucial Christian doctrines, such as creation, the incarnation of Jesus Christ, and His resurrection. It totally nullifies Christ’s shed blood, death, and resurrection as a means of salvation for mankind. Gnosticism simply became a religion of works, and, according to them, was meant only for those special elite who could discover the secret knowledge hidden within the Scriptures.

The origin of Catholicism

The damage that Marcion had done to the Christian Church at large was tremendous. Gnostics proudly claimed they were Christians and they alone had the corrrect doctrine. To help rid this belief system from the Church, the Roman Church headquarters, which held to the teachings of the original apostles, devised a way that would separate Gnostics from the “true Church.” A series of questions were devised that would point out “Gospel truth.” For the protection of the Church, the Roman Church put forth these questions in what was called “the Rule of Faith.” To receive water baptism and entrance into the Church, one had to respond in the affirmative to the questions of the Rule of Faith. Those questions gave distinguishing differences between those who followed the teachings of the original apostles and the Gnostics.

The Rule of Faith

“Do you believe in God the Father, Ruler of all?
Do you believe in Christ Jesus, God’s Son, who was born by the Holy Spirit through the virgin Mary,
was crucified under Pontius Pilate, died and was buried, and rose again on the third day,
alive from the dead, and ascended into heaven, sat at the Father’s right hand,
and will come again to judge the living and the dead?
Do you believe in the Holy Spirit, the holy church, and the resurrection of the flesh?”

The Roman Church wanted Christians to maintain correct doctrine and understand how their faith differed from Marcion’s false teachings of Gnosticism.

Marcion had argued that Christ’s Father had nothing to do with the physical world.
  
-
The “Rule of Faith” called God “Ruler of all.”
Marcion claimed that Christ was not human.
  
- The “Rule of Faith” confirmed Christ’s physical birth and physical death.
Marcion said the human body was beyond redemption.
  
- The “Rule of Faith” affirmed “the resurrection of the flesh.”

Handed Down From the Apostles of Christ

Every true Christian could accept the “Rule of Faith” because every word was a statement coming from Scripture as was handed down from the apostles. In that, the Roman Church was correct. The Gnostics, however, could not accept the “Rule of Faith.”

The Rule of Faith was later revised and became known as the “Apostles Creed.”

The Apostles' Creed
I believe in God the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth: And in Jesus Christ his only Son, our Lord; who was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the virgin Mary, suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, dead, and buried; he descended into hell; the third day he rose again from the dead, he ascended into heaven, and sitteth on the right hand of God the Father Almighty; from thence he shall come to judge the quick and the dead. I believe in the Holy Ghost; the holy catholic church; the communion of saints; the forgiveness of sins; the resurrection of the body; and the life everlasting.

To distinguish between the Christian Church that followed the teachings of the original apostles of Jesus and the churches of the cultic teachings of Marcion and others, the Roman Church, as the present headquarters for the Church at large in the Western Roman Empire created a name that would set the Church apart from all other false teachings. The word “Catholic” was established. In its original form, Catholic means “the teachings of the apostles as given by Christ.” Thus the Church, believers in the teachings of the apostles as given by Christ, took on the name “Catholic” to represent the universal church at large. The division within the Church at large was distinct. The Catholic Church opposed the Gnostic Church – which all claimed to be Christian. Those who called themselves Catholic openly claimed the apostles teachings as their own. The Gnostics could not. When two Christians met, one could ask of the other – “Are you Catholic?”  Their response would determine their Christian belief. Gnostic Marcionite Christianity survived for another 150 years and then, for the most part, died out. Only small remnants of it continued through the centuries. The Catholic Church, however, grew strong and survived.

The canonizing of the New Testament

The four Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, as well as most of the epistles were widely accepted by the Church at large by 120 A.D. There were no disputes among the churches - there just hadn’t been any official canonization done as of that time. During those few years that Marcion had authority from the Roman Church to rule over congregations, he tried to initiate the canonizing of the New Testament Scriptures by refuting or changing the Gospels already accepted within the Church. He especially didn’t like the book of Luke because it spoke about Jesus physical birth, life, and death upon the cross. The other gospel writings he wanted to change where there was any mention of Jesus’ physical presence. Remember that Gnosticism only believed in the spiritual, denying anything physical, so he wanted all reference to Jesus physical presence on the earth removed. He liked most of the Apostle Paul’s writings because they were more spiritual in nature. Any mention, however, of Jesus’ physical, Marcion fought to have it removed from the Scriptures, or have the complete book removed as one accepted within the Church. His early attempt to canonize the New Testament Scriptures only confused the people and end up halting the official canonization of the New Testament for another 200 years.

Who wrote the Gospel of Judas?

Gnosticism, like any other sect or religion always divides itself as humans disagree on doctrine. Since Sethianism was a twist of Gnosticism, Marcion, or one of his Gnostic followers, could have written the Gospel of Judas to support their heresy. Knowing its background points out its heresy as a violation of the whole Word of God, and shows how paganistic its beliefs actually were. There is no way that Jesus, nor any of His original apostles, could have spread a doctrine that would divide and stop true Christianity from continuing.

Website to the Gospel of Judas

If you would like to read an English version of the Gospel of Judas for yourself, it may be found on the following website: http://www.nationalgeographic.com/lostgospel/_pdf/GospelofJudas.pdf?fs=www7.nationalgeographic.com&fs=magma.nationalgeographic.com .  As a Christian, it is imperative to know and understand that all traditions, dogma, and doctrines had its beginnings somewhere in history, which has affected the Church at large – even today. When it affects the Church, it affects individual lives. Understanding Church history will help how we view God, the Bible, the world, and the Church. To learn more about church history during the 2nd century A.D. refer to the articles on Church History – 2nd century. Included within the series of articles is valuable knowledge from the 1st century A.D. to the 16th century A.D. Information regarding Church History from the Reformation to the present will be uploaded periodically.

End Notes

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

(1) http://www.kheper.net/topics/Gnosticism/Gnosticism_Neoplatonism_and_Psychology.htm
(2) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gospel_of_Judas

Last modified: Friday, 18 September 2009, 02:37 PM